Motion Detection Technologies: PIR vs. Ultrasonic Sensors

These days, motion detection devices are found everywhere: foreign or domestic houses, commercial establishments, and even public places. They offer security, decrease wastefulness, and ease people’s lives. Two of the most commonly used motion detection sensors are PIR sensors and ultrasonic sensors. Both are effective, but fundamentally, they function very differently. In this article, we will examine how these two compare concerning features and which one would be most suitable for your applications.

Check More PIR Sensor

What is a PIR Sensor?

A PIR sensor, or Passive Infrared Sensor, detects motion using infrared rays, which always present the normal radiation mode. Almost every object, especially living ones such as human beings and animals, has heat. A PIR sensor detects heat and changes thereof as an individual moves within its vicinity. Anytime it detects motion, it generates a response by sending a message to switch on a light or an alarm.

In simple terms, a PIR sensor is a passive sensor that does not actively transmit, emit, or radiate any waves to detect activity. It is only sensitive to changes in infrared radiation and, as such, does not actively radiate or use any energy.

What is an Ultrasonic Sensor?

In contrast to a PIR sensor, an ultrasonic sensor is an active device that sends sound waves. These sound waves produced are beyond the range of ordinary hearing. However, they bounce off objects returning to the sensor. Motion is detected because the amount of time these sound waves take to return to the sensor varies when the motion is seen, in this case, when someone walks in front of the sensor.

Their characteristic of sensitivity to motion is not limited to temperature changes such as heat from the human body. Thermal inertia of the objects within the field of view makes even static objects to be perceived as constantly moving.

How Do They Work in Motion Detection?

A PIR sensor detects motion through a change in infrared radiation, which is why it is ideal in areas that concern the movement of people or animals. It works much more effectively where there is a body temperature difference as well as a head difference. 

Meanwhile, ultrasonic sensors can recognize all types of motion occurring in the monitored area regardless of blood heat flushed into the skin surface. This is because some types of motion may involve objects or people moving without a noticeable temperature change.

PIR Sensor for security

The majority of PIR sensors are used in security systems, and they are widely used in most homes and office apartments. When a person enters a room or area, the camera senses this movement through its PIR sensor and activates alarms, cameras, or lights. This is effective in curtailing false alarms since it mainly considers the presence of a person based on heat illicit emission captured by the sensors.

These are sometimes good for security systems, ultrasonic sensors, and panic buttons. Automatic lighting is also fitted with PIR sensors, which are used in common areas lighting storage like corridors, toilets, and garages. When the sensor recognizes some individual moving into the room, its operation is turned on. When the same person rests in the area, or no more activity is perceived within a given period, the lights go off. This renders very efficient all automatic lighting PIR sensor systems design and energy consumption as it aids in eliminating electricity pollution.

Ultrasonic sensors may also be used in automatic light control, but they may be more prone to keeping the lights on for too long because even minor mobility, including air and pet movement, is registered.

PIR Sensor vs. Ultrasonic: Which is Better?

Both PIR sensors and ultrasonic sensors have some features that are in their favour. The PIR sensor is more energy efficient since it only detects heat movement, and no waves are transmitted, which could drain power. Also, it is very effective in sensing movements from the human body, which has made it useful in PIR sensors for security devices and automatic lighting commercial PIR sensor devices.

However, in situations where there is no visible variation in heat, ultrasonic sensors are more efficient in detecting motion. They are great, especially when persons or objects are in motion but do not produce any heat.

Conclusion

In the case of sensor motion detection technologies, major contributions have been made by PIR sensors and ultrasonic sensors. If you are looking for a low-priced and, at the same time, power-efficient and saving system, a PIR sensor would be the best option, especially when you want to implement a PIR sensor for security and automatic lighting PIR sensor systems. But if you need to sense motion, regardless of detecting temperature changes, all motion sensors would be desirable, hence achieving good results with ultrasonic sensors.

Once you recognize the benefits of these two technologies, you can decide which is the best solution for your house or business, be it a security system or an efficient lighting system.